The first thing that really hits you with this film is how different it is from the previous films, even PoA. There's something very pedistrian and "natural" about Newall's cinematography. It really hits you when they approach the sunrise on the hill where the portkey is, the camera is right there walking along with them, you actually feel you're trudging along with Harry + Co. on the hill. To put it plainly, Newall has taken the cinematic feel out of Harry Potter.
This isn't necessarlily a bad thing, because it really makes for great and fabulous moments. But it also does make simple moments duller than they should be. But I love this cinematic decision because ultimately we *want* to be part of the three tasks. We don't want the grandiose wideshot that says "
You're the audience...here's the film". Everything we see, even the reveals of the stadiums are done in a very real way, as if seeing through a helicopter, or just...being there. You actually feel you're in the mosh pit with the students at the yule ball. It really *really* does help out with the tense moments of the tasks in general which I'll rate:
1. The Dragons: I love dragons. They are my favorite mythical being, and easily my favorite task in the book. When I saw the commercials that involved Harry having to fly around the tower of Hogwarts, it leaved me a bit dismayed that the careful dancing protrayed in the book will made into a "replacement for Quidditch ack-shun," however the subtlties of Harry's thoughts would be hard to portray in general.
But like I said, the cinematic choice was excellent, especially the part where Harry is hanging on for dear life, and the Dragon is slowly progressing roof to roof. It really gives a sense that you're a student in a tower, just in awe at looking at the events unfold before your eyes.
2. The Lake: Swimming through the weeds were excellent, seeing the Merpeople city was amazing and subtle, much like how you enter a park. It slowly appears to you and then you begin to realize the scope of what lays before you. Surprisingly they made what could have been a really boring task into something interesting.
3. The Maze: Slightly disappointed by the absence of creatures in the maze, but it is for a good reason. They made the hedges alive instead, giving it a more sense of dread. This time however, the actors brought the dangers of the maze alive to us. In the book, I've always felt the maze was quite simple and pedestrian. There was no inherent danger compared to the other tasks. However Dumbledore had a great set-up, how people lose themselves while in the maze. Their fear, their actions, their ambition made the maze dangerous, more dangerous than it had to be...and personally it was a great set up for the graveyard scene.
But this film is far from perfect really. What really disrupted the film is the editing, the drastic cuts to another scene. It sadly reminded me of Star Wars: ROTS and how terrible it's editing was. It's really quite sad because this seems to be the first film really devoid of great transitional scenes into the next one, especially when referencing the change of seasons. Even just having the camera going from one scence to another...it's very jagged, which I suppose is the problem with the cinematography that I praised so much. Even the music doesn't flow well enough to bring the film together. If I were to say, this film was almost a bit TOO TIGHT.
Actors/Actresses PerformancesDan: Hate to say this about our main character, but he was the weakest actor of the trio. It's not to say he's bad, but he's inconsistent. Quite often he's wooden, talking his lines instead of acting them out. It's quite sad because a lot of his emotions seemed to be conveyed in stares, or at least the direction of the stare, which isn't necessarily bad, but compared to the ability of the other actors around him, he should pick up.
However his comedy is great, I'm quite surprised. The small moments with Ron is where he really shines, and he has his moments. His crying moment this time around is going to be under a lot of scrunity since a lot of people no doubt will compare it to his PoA performance...or even call it a repeat performance, but he did hit it on the head.
Rupert: Best of the trio easily. It's just not his ablility to make subtle facial gestures, but just his acting ability in general is really great. I wouldn't say pitch perfect considering that his looks is too fitting for the role they stuck him with, we'll have to see him in some other films, but he really shines in this film. Every moment he makes the best of it, and it shows. The anger at Harry was played perfectly.
Emma: Still the same from last time, very good, but it's very nice to see her have a bit more range of emotion given to her this time especially fear and distress. I really did feel sad for her after the Yule ball as Rupert was a total **** but it really shows the tension between those two.
The Twins: Love them PoA, and love them even more now. Seriously stole the SHOW. They are so in tune with their characters in the book, more than anyone really.
Dumbledore: I have to say, it's very fitting of DD to be like this for GoF, especially considering how GoF is the turning of the tide of the HP series from fun loving
Nancy Drew-esque solve a mystery romp, to actual dangerous adventures. Gambon Critics/Harris supporters are going to have a field day ripping into the performance, but I think the end dialogue between Harry and DD really did make up for all the qualms about him being too "
scary/mean". I didn't quite like the little homage to Harris with DD yelling out SILENCE, especially considering ATTENTION sounded better in the intro for the 3rd task.
Barty Crouch/Mad Eye Moody/et al: Mad Eye was a great glory to behold. Very good acting, top notch really. There is nothing I really can't say negatively about it. Barty Crouch was confusing because it seemed a bit bizarre on what his accent was. It never really "stayed" in one place, almost sounding French at times. What's even worst was how he kept that
jittery" feeling throughout the film, where in the Tri Wizard tournament it really should have been enough to voice his nervousness of knowing who done it. Maxine and Karkaroff were throwaways really. But they were good enough. Snape was pitch perfect as in PoA.
Peter Pettigrew: In what I would label the worst of the adult acting bunch. The thing is the book portrayed him sniveling through the entire ressurection process. In the film, he's quite devoted, even fanatical about helping out his master. It's appropriate for the personality they wanted to portray, especially when he barely winces in pain while holding his hand in a bloody stump. But I would have much preferred Pettigrew to be his sniveling way, motivated by fear, as opposed to his dedicated to his master route.
Voldemort: Oh yeah...the head honcho himself. I expected him to be paler, but now that I think about it...it freaking rocks. Really, it realy humanizes Voldemort to show how much of twisted monster he had become. Not because he doesn't look at all human anymore, but because how much remenants of humanity are left that disgust you.
I have to say, whenever I read about Voldemort, I never found him to be all that scary. A bit meloramatic, but never that frightening. Even when JKR made the comment that Voldemort was a
psychopath, I've never EVER really saw that attribute in him. I pitied him, I saw that he was evil, but never a psychopath.
But Fiennes did a MAGNIFICANT job of bringing the inner psychopath out from him. I'm used to the Jim Dale interpretation of Voldemort, but this one...is SO suited to what he's intended to be at least by the author. Just the way he moves, he acts...it so calculating, so spine tingly evil and graceful. It truly was his "
Red Dragon" all over again. The best part of it all....him dueling with Harry. Seriously even they were at a standstill, it just goes to show the power of Voldemort, even making me forget the lameness of the Star Wars fights from Episode 3.
So how does it match up? I'd still say that PoA is better, just as a more complete film. But the acting has progressed much better in GoF. So in order of favorite to least favorite:
PoA
GoF = PS
CoS
I'd give it 4.5/5.0 stars really.